Skip to main content

PSLE - a leveller or not?

I read the sentiments (published in the ST) below. While I agree that the PSLE is an objective exam and was effective in sorting students for many years, I feel that it is no longer a leveller in Singapore. 



When I sat the PSLE, whatever I knew, I learnt from school. Some of my peers did have private tutors, but they were not the norm. Expensive enrichment centres were unheard of. The students were more or less on equal footing then.  

These days, affluent parents send their children to enrichment centres, some of which provide notes that are more informative than what schools give. Exam questions are harder than before and those with extra hours of exposure outside of school hours have advantage over those who do not. How many students without tuition / enrichment / home support thrive in the PSLE? I personally do not know of anyone in this category. Unfortunately, statistics on the SES of students from each secondary school is not made known, so my views are merely anecdotal.

Schools also do their own streaming. Students who do well academically could be kept in the same high progress classes from Primary 3. It may be difficult for them to form friendships with students from other classes who may not perform as well as they do. Class divide may start as early as in primary school. 

In my opinion, DSA also benefits the wealthy. Rich parents send their children for various enrichment lessons from young. Among my peers, most of our children either play at least one musical instrument or are involved in a sport intensively. However, I have also met children whose family are of lower SES. These children struggle with their daily dosage of homework and are not sent for 'talent development' classes. It is not impossible, but it will be harder for them to rise above their more affluent peers. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Taiwan Trip Day 5 - Socks Museum, W & W Jewellery, Tamsui, Beitou and Banqiao Christmasland

Our final day in Taiwan was reserved for DIY activities, shopping and a hot spring experience. We had asked the taxi driver who took us to Leofoo if he could be our driver for this day as he seemed honest and his charges were reasonable (NT3200 for 8 hours and NT500 for every additional hour) and were glad that he was available.

Our first stop was the Wufuyang Socks Museum at Linkou. My friend had shown me pictures of her children's creations at this museum and I was looking forward to making soft toys. However, when we arrived, we were told that DIY activities were only available on Saturdays or when there was a group of 20 people or more. The staff on duty was very apologetic and he tried his best to make our visit fruitful. He did a demonstration of how a particular material could remain odourless even when ammonia was poured on it and showed us how to select socks that were of the right fit. We also bought a minion kit so that we could still make a soft toy, albeit in the comf…

T-hall

Dear children,

Another place we went to this holiday was T-hall at Crawford Lane (near Lavender MRT). For 1.5 hours, we scaled the walls and climbing structures at the challenge zone.


Inspired by J, Little An kept pushing herself up the colourful pillars till she reached the top. I was so proud of Little An overcoming her initial fears that I could be heard saying "Wow!" many times in the video recording her feat. Great job, Little An. J, you did very well in encouraging and showing your sister that getting to the top was possible. I myself only made it to the indigo pillar as I could not imagine myself leaping down from the highest pillar. I will try to get to the top the next time. :)



I was glad that both of you showed perseverance, even when some structures and walls were almost impossible to climb, like the Rubik's cubes and the crates. You both kept trying over and over again. I myself tried, so I knew how strenuous the climbing was. You both showed good determinatio…

Korea Trip Day 4 ~ Lotte World

On Day 4, we had a relaxing morning before proceeding to Lotte World.


We chose Lotte World over Everland as it had an indoor section, which would be able to withstand any weather. When we arrived at Lotte World, it was already 12.30p.m. My enthusiastic daughter opted to go on rides before lunch, and by lunch time, we had gone on five different rides, with a repeat on one of the rides. The rides were Drunken Basket, Jumping Fish (Little An's favourite), Dragons Wild Shooting, Lotty Train and Eureka, which required us to pump on a piston in order to fly.



By 1 p.m., we saw people laying picnic mats, all ready for the parade, which we thought was at 1.30 p.m. We had to contend sitting behind someone's mat at 1.20 p.m. as there were no 'front seats'. To my surprise, the parade was actually at 2 p.m., so we waited for 40 minutes before some entertainers appeared. The children enjoyed the parade though and were thrilled when some performers gave them high fives. My friend'…

Wonderland

Dear children,

I was imagining that this June holiday would be extremely busy for J since his PSLE is around the corner. In the end, he got away with only a couple of hours of studying a day, and lots of outings! We have gone to the Jewel four times since its opening and have enjoyed every visit!

One other place we went to was the Art-Science museum, where the Wonderland exhibition is going on. We were so impressed with the creativity of the exhibit. While queuing up, we were given an enchanted map each. There was a different character on each map.


We later found out that these maps could be scanned using machines located at different sections and the experiences for different map holders are unique. How exciting!


Three exhibits stood out for me. The first was the croquet game. Each person was given stickers to decorate the back page of his map, then the person would scan that page and have his photo taken, and voila! He appears as a playing card on a screen, joining other playing car…

Korea Trip Day 1 ~ N Seoul Tower

My last trip to Korea was in June 2007 and we had joined a tour group. This time, I was audacious enough to lug my five-year-old on a free and easy trip there in the cold month of March, knowing only two Korean words. Before the trip, I was gaping at the temperature charts (which showed that the temperature would range between -2 and 12°c during our trip), wishing that the country would heat up while we were there. I also added to the sales figures of Uniqlo by stocking up on its Heat tech products.

All my worries were unfounded. Our outer jackets (mine was a lightly padded one from Uniqlo while hers was a little more puffy one from Decathlon) managed to keep us warm throughout the trip. On most days, we wore three layers (extra warm Heat tech thermals, a shirt or jumper and our jackets) and we were comfortable.

The airport buses were easily located. We took Bus 6015 to Myeongdong and located our hotel after a short walk. What I was not prepared for was that Google maps do not provide…